Rodney Childers Rejects NASCAR CEO’s Claim and Raises an O’Reilly All-Star Race With Cup Drivers

Advertisement
  • Crew chief Rodney Childers rejected NASCAR CEO Steve O’Donnell’s claim that the O’Reilly Series car would look like Sunday’s Cup race with the top Cup drivers in it, per Motorsport.com.
  • Childers made his case on SiriusXM NASCAR Radio on Tuesday, November 17, and described an idea for an all-star race of 20 O’Reilly cars with Cup drivers behind the wheel.
  • Kevin Harvick and Dale Earnhardt Jr. have each laid out a plan of their own, and O’Donnell says NASCAR has no direct answer yet on the future of the Saturday car.

A Crew Chief Who Has Worked in Both Garages Says the Saturday Car Already Works

“I’ve done this a long time, and I disagree. These cars put on a good show.”

Rodney Childers said that on Tuesday, and he said it about a claim from the top of his sport. The future Hall of Fame crew chief, a champion in 2014, has worked in both the Cup Series and the O’Reilly Series. When he took his turn on SiriusXM NASCAR Radio, he went straight at the idea that Cup stars would turn the O’Reilly car into a copy of the Sunday show.

NASCAR’s position, more or less, is that the O’Reilly car would not be as good on Sundays with Cup teams and drivers racing it. The Saturday product has wide approval among fans and set decade viewership records this year on The CW Network. The O’Reilly car is an evolved version of the Car of Tomorrow, the Gen-5, so it races the way Cup cars used to. The Next Gen car on Sundays leans defensive, with its emphasis on track position and aero blocking.

What O’Donnell Said at Homestead

The remark Childers answered came from Steve O’Donnell, NASCAR’s CEO, at the State of the Sport press conference at Homestead-Miami Speedway earlier this month.

“If you put, you know, I talked to Tyler Reddick about this,” said O’Donnell. “I hope he doesn’t mind me putting him on blast, but he said, ‘Hey, if you put me and the top 10 Cup drivers in that series, it’s gonna look like Sunday as well.”

That is O’Donnell’s account of a conversation with Tyler Reddick. Reddick has not been quoted on it.

“So, you know, and it’s good racing. And so there’s a difference, right? These are conversations that have been going on, I think, since the 1970s of, ‘Hey, how do we improve the racing?’ And that’s the focus we always wanna have.”

“But as you look, you pointed out a definite issue or opportunity as well: what do we wanna race in that series going forward? So John (Probst) and the team are looking at, you know, where are the parts and pieces? How long can we sustain that? And then what’s the right move with whatever model we choose that can be an economical model that works for the car owners, the drivers, and ultimately helps grow the fandom.”

“So a lot of work being done, I’d say over the last two years, they’ve had conversations with the teams. No direct answer yet, but there’s a lot of work and a lot of investment, candidly, that’s been made into that future as well.”

Childers Answers From Experience

Childers joined JR Motorsports for 2026 as crew chief of its No. 1 Chevrolet in the O’Reilly Series. Earnhardt Jr. co-owns the team, and the two grew up together. On the radio, Childers started with the Homestead comments.

“I don’t know,” Childers said. “I mean I probably have different views on it now that I’ve been in it, because I heard the comments at Homestead about if you put the Cup drivers in it, it would look just like the Cup race.”

“They can run right up each other’s butts in the middle of the corner, and the cars still turn, and they still do normal things. And when you get close to somebody’s left rear quarter, you can make them loose.”

“That’s how we’ve all passed each other for years, you know, I mean all the way back to late models. When you turn the steering wheel left, it takes crossweight out. When you turn the steering wheel right, it puts crossweight in.”

“That’s race car 101. I mean, it’s just simple things that this car does right. I think the amount of downforce we have is very low. The cars aren’t that sensitive to the aero stuff under the car. I mean, there are things under there that’s a little sensitive, but nothing like what the new car is.”

He described an idea for settling it on the track, and it came with a number.

“We just had this conversation over the weekend about if we could just put together 20 of them and have an all-star race with Cup guys in it, just to see how it went.”

Praise for NASCAR, With a Catch

Childers did not set himself against the sanctioning body. He gave credit for the changes to the Next Gen over its first five seasons.

“Part of it is, we’re so wrapped up and so much money into what’s already changed, there’s hardly a way out of it. But they’ve also done a good job of making things better too. They’ve put on good races on the Cup side. They’ve made the tires better. They’ve made the aero better. They put more horsepower in them.”

“And I think they’re headed in the right direction. It’s just gonna take time to eventually get it perfect. Maybe perfect is not even the right word, because you’re probably never gonna get it perfect, but they’re working hard on it and, hopefully, like everybody keeps saying, they just leave our little thing alone.”

“And we’ll keep racing and putting on good shows.”

Harvick and Earnhardt Jr. Pick Their Sides

Kevin Harvick, the 2014 champion and a NASCAR on FOX analyst, spoke on his Happy Hour show on Wednesday, after O’Donnell dismissed the idea of another new car for the Cup Series in the coming seasons. His position on the Cup car is that it needs a Gen 7.5, and he agreed with Denny Hamlin, who recently called the Next Gen a sports car that was not meant for ovals.

“We don’t need Gen 8 car, but we need Gen 7.5,” Harvick said on his Happy Hour show this week. “You know, we took a lot of swings at it. I think we made some things better for sure but not as much as I think needs to be done.

“You’re going to have to look at the bottom of this race car, right? You’re going to have to look at some of the parts and pieces that you let the teams deal with and mess with. We can talk all day long about ‘the racing was good (on Sunday) at Homestead,’ but it wasn’t as good as Saturday.

“My point is you’re going to have to take a swing at stuff that you don’t want to take a swing at. If you really want to make it better, you’re going to have to change things on the race car you don’t want to change; because they’re probably expensive and you probably have a contract with who’s making the part”

“But if you really want to make it better, you’re going to have to make some harder decisions than changing the spoiler (size) and splitter (braces) and things like that.”

“I also don’t think changing the O’Reilly platform is the way to go,” Harvick said.

“But just make the trickle down start at O’Reilly’s now and go to Truck and ARCA and Late Models to make all of this right. Cup has to be great. And right now, everything is great on Fridays and Saturdays, great ratings on The CW, so worry about the Cup car. Don’t worry about screwing up the other two.

“Leave them alone. If you need to change the body, change the body. Fix the cup car. That’s what you got to concentrate on. And there’s going to be decisions that you’re going to have to make that are going to piss some people off.”

“It’s like putting power back in the car. We have been talking about more power. Everyone is like ‘we need some more power’ and they have finally come around to doing a little bit of it. Quit screwing around with putting a little bit in. Put a lot in. Just make it violent and crazy to watch.”

“I don’t want to be the jerk, but those are the facts,” Harvick said. “And if you really want to take a swing at it, you’re going to have to swing at things that you don’t want to swing at that are going to make some people mad. Engine, bottom of car, structure. It’s going to it’s going to open up a can of worms.

“That’s not going to be a lot of fun to deal with, but you’re going to have to deal with it if you truly want to make it a lot better.”

Dale Earnhardt Jr. owns a five car O’Reilly team, and he responded to O’Donnell’s comments on social media with a plan of his own. The O’Reilly chassis dates to 2011, and NASCAR has talked about moving that level toward a platform similar to the Next Gen car.

“Keep the current car, but made with new parts from NASCAR specified companies. The general concept of a NASCAR cup car is a mid 1960s Chevrolet Chevelle front clip and a mid 1960s pickup truck suspension in the rear. NASCAR teams spent decades refining this technology. Keep all of the general concepts and theories. Similar mounting points and such, all parts made by a NASCAR mandated manufacturer or two or three. Trailing arms, upper and lower control arms, spindles. You name it. Have designated companies produce it all. We could phase these parts in over the next 5 years and continue to race into the future a car we all have an extremely deep connection to.

“The Truck Series could use these same parts. They could trickle down to ARCA, Late Model Stock. There is enough racing going on between all levels of “stock car racing” that this could be lucrative to the specified manufacturers of said parts. It would be cost effective toward teams. It would create a pipeline of parts trickling down toward the grassroots levels of racing as they too are concerned over current parts and current and future scarcity. This is doable and maintains a key identifiable element to our industry.

“My fear is that the industry needs to create a trickle down model for the current Cup Next Gen car. Hubs, front and rear suspension, drivetrain. All these mileaged parts used to have a place to go and compete until the Next Gen was introduced. So there may be some who feel it’s common sense for the other 2 national series to adopt literal framework to utilize these pieces. No doubt Cup teams would like to have a marketplace for these parts. Time will tell but I have a feeling it’ll be really challenging to convince the league to keep the O’Reilly vehicle on its current architecture long term.”

What Comes Next

O’Donnell says NASCAR has no direct answer yet, and John Probst’s group is still studying parts, cost and the car owners’ interests. Three men with a stake in the Saturday car have now given three different answers. Kevin Harvick wants a Gen 7.5 for Cup and the O’Reilly platform left alone, Earnhardt Jr. wants today’s car rebuilt from specified parts, and Childers wants the car kept as it is. His 20 car all-star race came up in a weekend conversation, and nothing in what he said gives it a date or an entry list. The test in his idea is simple: put the Cup drivers in the Saturday car and see what happens.

Advertisement

James Rees

A passionate motorsport journalist from Wales, with over 30 years of love for the sport. A dedicated father of three, working as a staff writer and interviewer, covering the fast-paced world of Formula 1, Formula 2, Formula 3, Formula E, and IndyCar.

Leave a Comment