As Josef Newgarden enters the final year of his Team Penske contract in 2026, his future in IndyCar is quietly becoming one of the most intriguing storylines in the paddock. While Newgarden and Penske remain one of the most successful driver–team pairings of the modern era, a move to Arrow McLaren for the 2027 season could represent the ideal reset, and perhaps the best scenario for a driver looking to reassert himself at the very top of the sport.
2025 a Year to Forget
Josef Newgarden’s 2025 campaign was, by his own standards, a difficult one. Inconsistency, mechanical issues, and uncharacteristic DNFs five in total, left the two-time IndyCar champion and two-time Indianapolis 500 winner outside the title fight and searching for answers. Even though he ended the season with a win at Nashville, it felt more like a release than a turning point. Heading into 2026, Newgarden has openly spoken about the need for a “hard reset,” both personally and organizationally, a sentiment that aligns naturally with the appeal of a fresh start.
Read More: Who is the Last Rookie to Win the Indy 500?
Time for a Change?
Arrow McLaren represents exactly that. Over the past few seasons, the team has evolved from a promising project into a genuine powerhouse. With Pato O’Ward established as a perennial title contender, and Christian Lundgaard showing in 2025 his title desires alongside the organization consistently producing race-winning cars, McLaren has proven it can challenge Team Penske and Chip Ganassi Racing on equal footing. For Josef Newgarden, joining McLaren would mean stepping into a program that is hungry, aggressive, and still building, rather than defending decades of legacy.
The Final Piece of the Puzzle
From a competitive standpoint, McLaren’s Chevrolet alliance is another major draw. The team has increasingly maximized the package on both road and street circuits, areas where Newgarden has occasionally lacked consistency in recent seasons. Pairing his elite racecraft, oval dominance, and championship experience with McLaren’s data-driven approach could elevate both sides. In many ways, Newgarden could become the final piece McLaren needs to convert strong seasons into championships.
There is also a leadership angle that cannot be ignored. At Penske, Newgarden is one of several stars in a deeply established structure. At Arrow McLaren, he would immediately become a cornerstone of the team’s long-term vision. His experience, feedback, and winning mentality, sharpened through championship battles and Indy 500 triumphs, would be invaluable in shaping the organization’s next phase. For a driver entering his mid-30s, that level of influence can be just as important as raw pace.
Marketability and legacy also play a role. McLaren’s global brand, growing IndyCar presence, and crossover appeal align well with Newgarden’s stature as one of America’s most recognizable open-wheel drivers. A successful stint at McLaren would not only extend his competitive relevance but also redefine his legacy beyond Team Penske proving he can win, lead, and build success in more than one environment.
Finally, timing matters. A contract season often brings clarity, and Newgarden enters 2026 with nothing guaranteed beyond it. Arrow McLaren offers a rare combination of stability, ambition, and upside, a place where a motivated Newgarden could thrive immediately while also shaping the future.
Whether such a move ultimately materializes remains to be seen. But if Josef Newgarden is truly seeking the best possible scenario to reset, reenergize, and reestablish himself as IndyCar’s benchmark, a 2027 move to Arrow McLaren might be the smartest play of all.
From news to tech, history to opinions, We have a free Substack. To deliver the stories you want straight to your inbox, click here.
For more news and videos, follow us on Microsoft Start.
